Back to archive

The new Lip-Syncing of my generation and beyond

I sometimes call AI an intellectual Tylenol, although John Lloyd Cruz's Biogesic Ingat has been living rent-free in my head for years.

The new Lip-Syncing of my generation and beyond

This was me back in 1996 original footage, singing Tunay Na Pag-Ibig by the April Boys at one of my younger sisters' birthday celebrations. Before anyone accuses the sweaty little boy in the footage of lip-syncing, I was actually singing! Hahaha! The copy we have today seems to have some audio and video synchronization issues, although I cannot tell whether those came from the original recording, the transfer to a digital format, or one of the later conversions before my dad uploaded it. We might try restoring it when we have time, but even with the delay, the part I care about is still there, that child singing with his eyes closed, giving the performance everything he had, and having absolutely no idea whether the words coming out of his mouth were correct.

I did not even know how to read back then. Yes, roast me if you want, but throughout those toddler-to-kid years, my dad could pick up his guitar or turn on the karaoke and I would sing along with whatever I remembered, even when several parts of the lyrics returned an HTTP 404. Confidence lang talaga, seryoso! When I entered first grade the following year, I learned to read Tagalog, and suddenly I had another way to check what I thought I was hearing. It did not mean I became a professional singer overnight, but it taught me something that I can appreciate only now, and that is confidence got me to open my mouth, while learning to read helped me understand what I was actually singing.

So, 3 decades later, with a different face and considerably more vocabulary, I sometimes wonder why that willingness to show an imperfect version of ourselves becomes so difficult to carry into adult life. We can spend hours polishing an email tang ina heto na naman tayo because we are afraid a coworker will judge a sentence, or rehearse a response to a customer until it sounds nothing like the way we normally talk. I do not think that every hesitation is bad because professionalism and consideration for other people matter. But there is an uncomfortable difference between trying to communicate clearly and refusing to let anyone see that we are still learning. It makes me ask whether AI really took away some of our confidence to think and communicate, or whether we had already started hiding behind polished versions of ourselves long before AI came to the game.

I lean toward the latter. Humans were decorating the raw version of themselves long before anyone could type a prompt into a chatbot, whether by borrowing impressive words, copying another person's style, or trying to sound certain about something they barely understood. The arrival of AI did not invent our appetite for that kind of armor because it simply made the armor much easier to produce. In a few seconds, an awkward message can become a flawless corporate email, a half-formed thought can turn into a confident paragraph, and a person who is unsure of an idea can suddenly sound as if they have been defending it for years. That convenience can be useful, and I use it myself, but I get uneasy when the polished output stops being a tool for expressing our thoughts and becomes the only version of us that we are willing to show.

Take grammar as an example. If mine is weak, I would welcome a tool that fixes a sentence, especially when the message needs to be clear and the recipient should not have to decode my intentions. But I would also want to know why the sentence was wrong, because repeatedly submitting the same weakness to a machine is not quite the same as learning how to address it. The same goes for reading comprehension, listening, and speaking, getting help with a difficult task is not automatically evidence that the underlying skill enhanced. I sometimes call AI an intellectual Tylenol, although John Lloyd Cruz's Biogesic Ingat has been living rent-free in my head for years. Hehe! A pain reliever can make discomfort manageable without necessarily fixing its cause, just as AI can make a piece of work presentable without guaranteeing that I have developed the ability to do it myself.

That is where the title of this journal comes from. By new lip-syncing, I am not making an allegation about any singer or dance group, nor am I pretending that prerecorded vocals and backing tracks have no legitimate place in entertainment. I am talking about an intellectual habit because allowing a machine to produce words that sound like our competence, presenting them as if we fully understand them, and then becoming less interested in whether we could explain the same idea ourselves. We might deliver an impressive paragraph during a meeting or send a polished reply to a customer, but if someone asks us to unpack the reasoning, will we still recognize the voice behind it? The concern is not the act of receiving help. It is the possibility that we become comfortable performing understanding without doing the work of understanding.

Whenever I think about that distinction, I also think about performers such as BINI in Pantropiko and the Baby Dolls performing Ikembot Mo. The videos are not proof of how each vocal track was produced, and I am not using them to make claims about anyone's live singing. What interests me is the visible work of performance, especially the coordination, rhythm, timing, memory, and physical practice that choreography demands. There is no magic prompt that teaches a body to move in formation without rehearsal. And before anybody misunderstands me, I am not suggesting that dancers in YouTube Shorts or TikTok videos somehow count less as performers. A short clip may contain serious craft, just as a big production may still have flaws, the length of the video and the platform carrying it are not substitutes for looking at the work itself.

That is not the skill I am asking everybody to develop. I am asking why we can easily recognize that dancers and singers improve through practice while treating our own reading, writing, speaking, and listening as inconveniences to be skipped whenever a tool can produce something more elegant. Of course, we have jobs to finish, people to help, and a limited amount of energy. Not every email deserves to be analyzed as though it were a dissertation. There are good reasons to use AI for summaries, drafts, and repetitive work. But there is a point where convenience can become avoidance, especially when we keep asking for summaries of emails, tickets, cases, and conversations that nobody eventually reads in full. Sometimes even the summary gets summarized until the entire workflow looks beautifully organized, yet the crucial detail sits untouched in the original message. Aminin? May ganito tayong moments. Hehe!

The problem becomes more serious when a summary is mistaken for verification. A machine can produce a concise account of a customer issue, but it cannot make an overlooked attachment disappear from reality, and a confident sentence is not a substitute for checking the evidence behind it. I have no interest in romanticizing manual work, because there are tedious tasks that technology should absolutely help us eliminate. What I want to preserve is the human responsibility to notice when we have not understood something, to ask a question when an explanation is unclear, and to return to the source when the stakes deserve more than a convenient abstraction. If AI gives us more time to do those things, then great. If it becomes an excuse to stop doing them, then we have exchanged one problem for another and decorated the exchange with perfect grammar.

Maybe that is also why I hesitate to let AI turn my writing into an entirely different person. I am happy to have my spelling corrected, my evidence challenged, and my sentences rearranged when the argument gets lost along the way. I do not expect every awkward phrase to survive simply because it came from me, but I still want the finished piece to sound like something I could defend across a table, including its jokes, Taglish, occasional profanity, and the parts where I admit I am uncertain. If I cannot explain what the journal claims without asking a machine to explain it back to me, then Tang ina, hindi rin ako iyon, gago! It may be a smoother piece of writing, but I would have lost the very reason I wanted to write it.

Which brings me back to that child in 1996. I am not sharing the footage to flex, and not to conduct a public humiliation of my younger self. It is a small surviving record of the canonical me at a particular moment. When I was sweaty, eyes closed feel na feel, singing despite not knowing all the words. Learning to read the following year did not erase that kid. Because it gave him another tool to make sense of what he loved doing. That, to me, is the better relationship with technology too. Let a tool help us learn, correct, and improve, but do not ask it to replace the person who still has something to practice.

And for the record, even with all the reading I have done since first grade, there are still 404s in my music library. Whenever I sing Taylor Swift's Blank Space, my brain sometimes insists that she is singing about Starbucks lovers. Apparently, 30 years of technological progress have not patched that particular bug. At least I can hear myself making the mistake, laugh at it, and try again, which is more than I could say if I outsourced even the voice doing the singing.

I would rather have a few 404s in my own voice than become so dependent on a polished replacement that I no longer recognize the person doing the talking.